It's quality has declined through the years..
I've been eating here for years and the past few times have made me decide that I will never go there again. Delivery man 30 minutes late, my pizza was undercooked and doughy, crust just had a really weird/bad taste, rude service, and wrong order. This has happened consistently.
Great local pizza, buffalo chicken!.
This was my favorite college pizza joint, and now years later it's still a treat to eat here again. I eat pizza far more often than any human should (nearly every other day) and love all the different kinds. Kingston pizza is the best all around local-style pizza. It's the medium-thin pizza (not super thin like NY) with very good standard Italian varieties (great pepperoni pizza), but also very inventive and atypical but great "special" flavors. Crazy names and combinations like the 911, Firehouse, Thunderbird, etc. Many are good but intimidating (lots of ingredients) and a bit much. I love the Buffalo chicken pizza ("Thunderbird"), the best of it's kind I've had anywhere. Highly recommended, both their pizzas and calzones. Supposedly the sandwiches are great too, though I haven't tried any.