O'scugnizzo Pizzeria

Recommends

Mitch Schenkel

Joined 2 years ago

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria. I have never eaten or ordered at the one in Washington Mills, but I have eaten and ordered at the one on Genessee St. and have always had a good pizza. Always had a hand made crust, good toppings and always delicious. I would make inquiries into whether the manager at the one you ate at is having a problem. This is the only pizzeria my brother-in-law will order from when he is in town from Binghamton.

Doesn't Recommend

durhams

Joined 5 years ago

ROTTEN VEGETABLES!! Horrible experience!. We decided to order pizza from O'scugnizzo in Washington Mills and were horribly disappointed in the product!! The pizza was much smaller than we had anticipated and obviously just a pre-made pie with sauce poured over the top; the wings were adequate at best, but the crowning disgust were the ROTTEN celery and carrots! Actually ROTTED!!! Where is the Board of Health?? Obviously this place is not clean, and takes no pride in their food, nor any regard or respect for their customers. Needless to say, we will NOT be back and will tell everyone we know to do the same.

Recommends

msi6340m

Joined 9 years ago

The Original. This is the second oldest Pizza place in the country only Lombardi's in New York City is older.... This is the pizza that Joe's in Whitesboro try to be as is Yetty's in Herkimer...Both are very good mind you but not as good as O'Scugnizzo's . Try the OSP special with garlic, tomatoes and sausage !!! Subs and daily specials are very resonably priced and very generous portions as is their chicken wings...HUGE !!!