Pie In The Sky Pizza

Recommends

Paul R.

Joined 9 months ago

Great pizza here.

Recommends

Steven K.

Joined 2 years ago

Delicioso. PIe In The Sky Pizza is tied for my favorite pizza spot in Cashville! From the Pizza to the pasta, wings and beers, hands down amazing!

I recommend the all meat pizza here. It has plenty of toppings and the garlic butter crust is awesome.

The pizzas here are comparable to MMushroom cost wise. So it isn't the cheapest in town, but it beats Papa J's or P Hut for quality in my opinion.

Give this place a try if you are on the fence!

Recommends

R P.

Joined 2 years ago

Can it get much better that this?. I don't think so! I've been going to Pie In The Sky since it first opened. Now however, the Lenox Village location provides a more convenient pizza destination.

I love the ambience here and the service has always been good as well. If you go, definitely try the pizza. I haven't wandered to far from the pies here.

In a world full of pizza choices, Pie has always been my spot for a fresh quality pizza.

Recommends

KaraRobinson

Joined 2 years ago

Top notch service. I was really impressed with the service at pie in the sky. My waitress was very helpful with menu suggestions. This is something I really value in a dining experience. She suggested I order a Happy Family pizza with black olives. Apparently this is a popular pizza at pie in the sky. I can see why! Also tried the cookie dough ala mode dessert to top off the evening. I will be back and I will be asking for Tara again.

Recommends

sammieyork

Joined 2 years ago

"Two thumbs way up!". Went in for lunch today at pie in the sky after receiving a coupon in a coupon book I received in the mail. I thought it was great. The southwest chicken salad was good, especially the with the beautiful avocados (see the picture posted above).

Recommends

EGSutter

Joined 2 years ago

Reminds me of Cheers. A few friends and I grabbed a pizza here last night. Thankfully we came on Tuesday because it was 2 for 1 Fat Tire night. My favorite! The buffalo wings and a sausage pizza hit the spot! We sat in the bar area and chatted with the bar tender. What a nice guy! The whole experience reminded me of Cheers.

Recommends

Hannah Small

Joined 2 years ago

nom nom nom. I'm new to the lenox village area, so I decided to try some of the local area restaurants. Dined at Pie In The Sky two nights ago. Loved it! I will definitely be going back. #nom nom nom

Doesn't Recommend

ltrayne

Joined 4 years ago

Major Miss. Nashville, you can do better than this.

Cost for one with 20% tip: $22.84 (no alcohol)

-small pizza one topping

-twisty mozerella bread

-diet coke

Most pizza places in New York will do ya better for less...

The mozzerella twisty roll thingy, essentially their answer to "garlic knots" had no taste. It was cooked nicely, doughy and soft, but the dough had no salt sprinkled on top, no garlic, no oil, just bread with tastless gooey cheese in side. Ate only half (my wife is eating the other half as I write this-same opinion)

The pizza: small with italian sausage. crust looks and tastes deep fryed. I don't even know how you achieve this in a pizza oven. It was also extremely bland, couldn't taste the cheese, again, no salt, no garlic, very oily. The worst was the wierd grainy texture from what appears to be corn meal that covers the crust on the bottom. Like sand.

Doesn't Recommend

tim thomas

Joined 2 years ago

How do you call this Pizza. For a place with pizza in the name you should be ashamed. The Pizza is not good at all. The salads are the only things I have enjoyed both times I have been there and will not be going back now that there are a few other options down nolensville road.

Doesn't Recommend

danik123

Joined 2 years ago

@ strikes and your out. Have been to Pie in the Sky twice in last 2 months and will never go back. First experience was bad and I figured it was a bad night so I tried again and second visit was just as bad. Pizza is like having White bread with cheese and sauce and I could have bought better from Publix Frozen section.