Not Your Average Joe's

(978) 462-3808

Firehouse Center Market Square
Newburyport, MA 01950 42.8127 -70.8816

Get Map & Directions »

Hours:

Monday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Tuesday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Wednesday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Thursday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Friday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Saturday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Sunday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Price:

$$

Last updated 10.31.11

Category:

Restaurants, Dessert Shops

Payment Methods:

Gift Certificate, American Express, Cash, Visa, Discover, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Romantic Dining, Outdoor Dining, Business Dining, Lunch Spot, Date Spot, Group Dining

Cuisine:

Pizza, Traditional American, Soups, Seafood

Smoking Permitted:

No

What People Are Saying About Not Your Average Joe's

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

The Scene – Each Joe's location handles a steady flow of hungry families and casual couples tired of national chains' bland cuisine and soulless atmospheres. While most nights bring standing-room crowds, waiting for a table can be avoided by sitting at the bar (the better to sample from a surprisingly varied, yet affordable, wine list). Servers, while kept in constant motion by the hungry masses, manage to keep baskets of spongy focaccia filled. – – The Food – While most diners come for the eclectic, stone hearth oven-baked pizzas (shrimp and artichoke, spicy…

Editor's Tips

Save Time:
While reservations aren't taken, it's wise to call ahead and get your name on the waiting list.
Save Money:
Hit the restaurant's homepage for special offers and weekly specials.
ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. Great location
  2. Excellent location in Newburyport's charming downtown, and with an open view of the water.
  3. The variety and atmosphere is great.
  4. Wonderful view of the water in the back room.
food quality
90.90999603271484% positive
  1. great food
  2. If you want to taste to great italian pizza, this restaurant is where you want to go.
  3. Love the bread!
  4. It was one of the best meals i've had (mustard chicken) There was seven kids.
  5. guess every meal in a US Italian restaurant starts with bread and their is a pleasant foreshadowing of what is to come.
  6. NYAJ's is a great place to drop in and get a good variety of food.
  7. love the bread and dipping sauce while you wait.
  8. Steak tips are great as are the salads and pizzas.
  9. Huge menu, fabulous food, terrific service (fast and nice waitstaff), reasonably priced.
  10. My food is often cold, the waitstaff is not trained to be polite, when the food does come its doesn't taste right.
  11. Fun place for the family to enjoy a meal.
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. The menu is extensive with new items appearing regularly.
  2. The variety and atmosphere is great.
  3. NYAJ's is a great place to drop in and get a good variety of food.
  4. Huge menu, fabulous food, terrific service (fast and nice waitstaff), reasonably priced.
overall
100.0% positive
  1. NYAJ's is a great place to drop in and get a good variety of food.
  2. If you want to taste to great italian pizza, this restaurant is where you want to go.
service
100.0% positive
  1. Huge menu, fabulous food, terrific service (fast and nice waitstaff), reasonably priced.
  2. The staff was really pleasant and very accomodating.
4 Star Rating: Recommended

08/31/10

Exceptional Service

by Ben Murawski

The other night my wife,and another couple decided to eat out at Not your average Joe's. I wasn't sure, It wasn't my pick although the ladies get what they want. We were seated and greeted by our server "Ella" she was very courteous and knowledgeable. Our food was relatively quick and any time we needed anything she was right on top of it. Everything was very pleasant, the food was exceptional and our drinks were perfect. Overall it was a real nice experience, we will be coming back, Thanks

1 Star Rating: Poor

07/18/10

Bland, boring, and uninspired

by Entil Zha

We live nearby, and have been exploring Newburyport's restaurant scene. We decided to try Joe's one evening, and initially were excited. There are lots of interesting sounding dishes on the menu. Then reality set in as I saw a nearby family's main courses taken back for re-preparation because they weren't satisfactory.

One dish's beef tips were well prepared, but the accompanying green beans were barely cooked (almost raw) and very tough. The other vegetable (zucchini & squash) had been lightly sauteed and was almost flavorless.

My chicken was cooked well, but the highly vaunted (and recommended) cranberry-teriyaki glazesauce had no flavor. What cranberry? I couldn't taste it! It was served with mushy , almost flavorless sweet potato cannellonis beneath which lay a bed of flavorless spinach.

I mentioned the problems to the waiter, who cleared our main course and dropped off the check without asking if we wanted either dessert or coffee. Sorry, but if this is how this place treats its food (and customers) we won't go back.

This place advertises itself as "not average" but is not living up to this claim. Maybe they were having a bad night, but I really doubt that.

  • Pros: Nice harbor view. Friendly staff
  • Cons: Service marginal. Food even worse
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/07/08

The Best Pizza

by twinziam

The pizza here is not your average pizza. If you want to taste to great italian pizza, this restaurant is where you want to go. Generous portion and well cooked. The staff was really pleasant and very accomodating. I did not find them slow at all. The wait wasn't too long, pretty much the same standard as other establishments. Not to mention, the scenery is beautiful especially in the summer. I really enjoyed my dinner here and would recommend this eatery. I will definitely go back again for my pizza cravings!

  • Pros: Location, Scenery, Fresh Food, Service
  • Cons: None
4 Star Rating: Recommended

02/21/08

Love the bread!

by sjc07

Every once in a while its nice to have a menu change! BUT other than that, this place is cool, literally, its always cold in there. The waitstaff are usually very nice. Sometimes slow but nice. The menu has been the same for years but it always taste good! Great for the whole family! Definately make reservations if you can...

  • Pros: Delicious bread, delicious mixed drinks, yummy food!
  • Cons: need a menu change...variation is nice!
4 Star Rating: Recommended

10/30/07

The bread and dipping Sauce!!!!!!!

by petesmith345

I guess every meal in a US Italian restaurant starts with bread and their is a pleasant foreshadowing of what is to come. Their meals are fair priced and great quality.

  • Pros: Great Food
  • Cons: sometimes there is a wait

The Details on Not Your Average Joe's

Place Categories:

  • love bread
  • polite service
  • love place
  • huge menu
  • great location
  • nice waitstaff
  • very accomodating staff
  • great variety
  • enjoy meal
  • terrific joe
  • great steak tips
  • pleasant foreshadowing
  • great atmosphere
  • wonderful view
  • love dipping sauce
  • beautiful scenery
  • cool but
  • really enjoyed dinner
  • great hamburgers
  • delightful dipping oilcheese
  • great italian pizza
  • fabulous food
  • recommend eatery
  • charming downtown
Advertisement

Recent Reviews In Newburyport

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Davids Tavern

11 Brown Sq, Newburyport, MA

Advertisement