Mystic Fish Seafood Grill

Recommends

CSMobileUser2

Joined 5 years ago

Table not ready. food great but table not ready when reserved. these folks gave grown beyond their ability to mange

Recommends

HerbalRPh

Joined 4 years ago

Hidden Gem in Tampa Bay area. I would highly recommend Mystic Fish to you but I don't want it to become to crowded. This is a hidden gem in an area of Tampa Bay not often thought of for Good Food.

I travel for a living and LOVE great food, service and wine list and will go great lengths to find all three. This hits all three out of the park. The regular menu is always my standby. The daily features are always very creative and perfectly prepared. It might be pricey for some, but I found out years ago that you get what you pay for when it comes to great food. The atmosphere is average yet interesting.

The chef will even accommodate special requests and needs---even on a busy night. I have had business dinners, family dinners and dates here and all have always been great. You can always tell a great restaurant by the lack of turnover in wait staff. Most waiters have been working here since I moved here 7 years ago.

Recommends

detnative

Joined 5 years ago

Love this place!. This gem has excellent food and service, a perfect place to enjoy an intimate, leisurely dinner away from it all. Try the pork osso buco, yum. It is reasonably priced considering the variety and quality of the food and drink. I enjoy the interesting, contemporary decor too.

Recommends

mfrayn

Joined 8 years ago

Great Menu, nice staff. The place was packed so we ate at the bar. Both bartenders were friendly and attentive. The menu was excellent. We both ended up picking specials off the menu and thoroughly enjoyed them. A very contemporary and eclectic place. Spent about $100 for dinner and drinks for two people.

Recommends

me123456789

Joined 6 years ago

Overpriced and fake grouper. Very trendy, but over priced for what you get. Service is average, very clean, good place for a date or clients.

Recommends

katydid271

Joined 6 years ago

Excellent Seafood. I went for an early dinner and was pleasantly surprised by the food. The springroll appetizer has an interesting flavor and is a nice change of pace for pre-dinner fare. The cilantro-lime vinaigrette was very good on a well-made salad. The sea bass was excellent and nice to see on a menu b/c it has been hard to come by lately and they did a great job with its presentation. The surf and turf fusion was probably the best steak I have had and the lobster was good as well. Our waiter was very attentive. They have the added benefit of an early dinner menu and happy hour drink specials every night until 6:30. I would not hesitate to return.

Recommends

wine3

Joined 7 years ago

9 year anniversary. I am so happy to see the quality in everything is strong. As we visit twice a month many of the same servers are still there. On our last visit they have added small plates and many great wines. Thank you for serving Palm Harbor so well.

Recommends

honestreview1

Joined 7 years ago

great menu and interior, good service, a must try.. Give this Tampa Bay restaurant a try. Greeted with a smile at the door.Give the Seabass with hijiki sauce, Kona Crusted Rib Eye, Bison Tenderloin, and fresh local Black Grouper a try. Service is attentive. Wine list affordable, even the Caymus. Would make reservations on the weekends. This is Palm Harbors best kept secret.

Recommends

m_atteniese

Joined 7 years ago

very creative food. Went for the first time last Saturday and all in all I thought the food was excellent. Very different ecclectic menu. Good wine list and great service. The decor was really cool. The owners are the same as Guppy's and E & E steak out grill and I like both those places as well. This place was more upscale than the other two.

Doesn't Recommend

foraker3

Joined 7 years ago

Bad Experience. The food was just ok, very overpriced, the garlic mashed potatoes were from a box. The seaford especially the crab cakes were lousy...my pork chop was very tuff...the waitress came back and wanted more tip, never have I ever been so embarrassed, we tipped on the bill not the tax, she wanted $3 more dollars, can you believe that? We spend $63.00 for two people. There were 3 other people in our party they paid on a separate check.