Jerry's Pizza & Italian Rstrnt

12/31/09

Great place...

by cjsettle at Citysearch

My husband and I have made several trips to Jerrys on past vacations, and we absolutely love it. Each visit has been positive, with great waiters and excellent food. We are absolutely stuck on their stromboli, and the portions are huge!

• Pros: Best Stromboli

09/04/09

Great place to eat.

by Mel2 at Citysearch

When we visit P.I. we always stop in and eat at Jerry's. Great pizza and salads. Informal nice atmosphere.

• Pros: Right on the beach and near lighthouse.
• Cons: None.

04/16/09

Closes pizza 2 New York

Contributor at Citysearch

"Don't judge Jerry's pizza by the the name you need to go in and try it for yourself!! The pizza is pit of this world and they also have a shrimp Sinatra that will knock your socks off!!! Had great experience at jerry's pizza that will tell all my friends about. It's a mom and pop store with many dishes to offer. Portions are plenty to tale home for left overs,

03/08/09

Jerry's OK By Me

by keysy at Citysearch

Jerry's is your classic hometown pizza joint, not a tourist trap or a gourmet restaurant by any means. But our experiences have been good there. Pizza dough could use a little more butter or flavor seasoning, but it wasn't bad. The last time we were there the waitress was pretty busy with a full house and only her taking orders but she kept her cool. Many locals are trying to get me to try Pete's Pizza at the corner of Nova and Beville. They say it's the best around. That's my next stop.

• Pros: Hometown pizza joint. Great place to hang out with friends.
• Cons: There are better pizzas around if you want to find them. Jerry should upgrade his pizza dough recipe.

06/29/08

best pizza in town

by John98765 at Citysearch

I love this place, best pizza in town. Not sure what the other comment is about. I've never had a bad experience there, there pizza is great (truly my favorite). I like it so much I've told all my friends to go there... (and they always tell me they loved it too)

I also notice the name of the poster (The Genevieve) who put up the negative review, and The Genevieve happens to be the name of another italian restaurant nearby... hmmm. Thats aweful. Shame shame