Destination: Fire Island

Updated: April 04, 2002

Boardwalks, crowded bars, quiet dunes and a no-cars policy make this dreamy Long Island spot a favorite Hamptons alternative for New Yorkers looking to get away. Accessible only by ferry, it's a breeze to find solitude at Ocean Beach on Fire Island, but come sunset, finding peace and quiet depends on where you stay at night.

On this page:What to Do, Where to Eat and Drink, Where to Stay.

What to Do

  1. 1 William Floyd Estate
    Write a review

    245 Park Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951 (map)

    He signed the Declaration of Independence. Now you can visit his former abode, a National Park historic site offering a glimpse into the past.

  2. 2 Fire Island Lighthouse Prsrvtn
    Write a review

    4640 Captree Is Ste C8, Captree Island, NY 11702 (map)

    Built in 1857, this island landmark has been fully restored to its 19th-century glory. Take a guided tour, or skip the history lesson and wander inside to enjoy the panoramic view of the Atlantic ocean.

Where to Eat and Drink

  1. 3 4 Star Rating: Recommended Matthew's Seafood House Inc
    Read Reviews

    935 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 (map)

    A mostly-local crowd downs thick and creamy bowls of New England clam chowder while lounging on the restaurant's popular bayside deck. After dark, a younger crowd takes over and the scene turns more lively.

  2. 4 4.5 Star Rating: Recommended Rachel's Bake Shop
    Read Reviews

    325 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 (map)

    Vacationers can offset any post party stomachache by binging on a stack of pancakes and a strong cup o' joe at this casual spot, where lengthy breakfasts tend to trespass upon lunch hour.

  3. 5 2 Star Rating: Below Average Island Mermaid
    Read Reviews

    780 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 (map)

    A spacious restaurant serves three meals a day, plus brunch on weekends. Bring the kids to dine out on the deck and order off the kids' menu.

  4. 6 4 Star Rating: Recommended Grove Hotel & Ice Palace
    Read Reviews

    Main Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782 (map)

    Grab a slice at Grove Pizza and then head upstairs for cool cocktails, hot parties and people-watching at this upscale bar, located in the center of Fire Island's thriving gay community.

  5. 7 4.5 Star Rating: Recommended Flynn's Ocean Bay Pk
    Read Reviews

    1 Cayuga St, Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770 (map)

    When the 'rents call it a night, the island's younger population convenes at this local spot to enjoy happy hour drink specials featuring frozen margaritas, a pool table, an outdoor terrace and music provided by a DJ.

Where to Stay

  1. 8 3 Star Rating: Average Clegg's Hotel
    Read Reviews

    478 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 (map)

    Stay right in the center of Fire Island facing the Great South Bay and enjoy a five minute walk to the ocean and just as easy access to nightlife.

  2. 9 4 Star Rating: Recommended Dune Point Fire Island Rentals
    Read Reviews

    134 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782 (map)

    Whether staying in a studio or a one or two bedroom apartment, the setups of these beachside rentals, complete with do-it-yourself kitchens and dining areas, are ideal for families.

  3. 10 2 Star Rating: Below Average Houser's Hotel
    Read Reviews

    781 Evergreen Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 (map)

    It's tough to block out the clamor from the adjacent Houser's Bar, so the simple accomodations here are optimal for partygoers and not those looking for peaceful evenings.

  4. 11 4.5 Star Rating: Recommended Seasons Bed & Breakfast
    Read Reviews

    482 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 (map)

    Need a child-free guarantee to really kick back on vacation? There are no kids allowed at this B&B, where couples can enjoy the hospitality reserved for especially for adults.

  5. 12 3.5 Star Rating: Average Belvedere Hotel
    Read Reviews

    33 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782 (map)

    It's men-only at this ornate, Venetian-style hotel in Cherry Grove. Guests can even spend the night without having to pack a suitcase: A clothing-optional policy applies thorught the hotel.

Advertisement